This is very helpful. Thanks!
I had and idea for a replacement action called Intuit which I think follows some of what you suggest. I was also considering allowing my players to come up with their own replacement action if they had something unique.
Anyway here’s what I have proposed to my players (obviously much of this language is cribbed from the book):
Replace ATTUNE with INTUIT.
When you INTUIT, you quickly gain an understanding of a situation,
being or system you are directly interacting with. You may be able to
draw accurate conclusions about a device or person in the moment
with little evidence. You might sense lies, hidden truths or other
interactions that are at play. INTUIT can be rolled only once for any
given situation. It is your first impression. To revise or refine your
thinking requires STUDY.
GM QUESTIONS
• What details do you focus on? What kinds of things are you looking for?
• What do you hope to understand? What problem might you be trying to solve?
When you INTUIT, you take in the information around you — hidden
interactions, facts, intentions, disperate clues — to deduce what
may not be obvious otherwise. INTUIT differs from STUDY in that it
comes from instinct rather than intellect and, unlike STUDY,
happens instantly. Unlike other ACTIONS, on rare
occasions the GM might ask for an INTUIT roll from a player in
certain situations.
You can use INTUIT to “read a person” to judge whether
they’re lying, what they really want, what their intentions are, etc.
When you INTUIT someone in this way, you can ask the GM
questions while you interact with them. You might wait until they
say something fishy, and then ask the GM, “Are they telling the
truth?” If you want to know someone’s intentions, you might use
INTUIT to sense what is really going on.
You can also INTUIT a situation or a place. Revealing clues, finding
out who’s in charge, figuring out why the gang you’ve worked with
before is acting odd, might all fall under an INTUIT roll whether
any clues are present or not.
When you suspect that something is hidden when you confront a
situation or system that you do not understand, you may use
INTUIT to get a sense of what is hidden or how the system
works so that you can interact with the system to accomplish your
goals.